Spreading Holiday Cheer

One Cookie at a Time!

Free Shipping on Every Order over $60

Shop Now

Shop holiday 2023:

Specialty Cookie Holiday Gift Box

From $26.95

Holiday Cookie Kit

$34.95

Holiday Gift Box Cookies by the Dozen

$29.95

Gingerbread House Kit

$39.95

Holiday Big Box of Sweets

$136.95
View all

You're Invited!

Youngstown's Ultimate Cookie Exchange

$20.00

There's more than one way to enjoy One Hot Cookie!

send to a friend today

We ship the cookie goodness across town or across the country. Order online for shipping or in-store pickup.

Mobile parties

Book our almost-famous Cookie Camper to sweeten your next party or event.

REserve YOur Date Now

Visit us in store

Swing into our flagship location in Boardman, Ohio. (You'll see what we did there when you visit us!)

FREE SHIPPING ON EVERY ORDER OVER $60